Menu of Emack & Bolio's Ice Cream: Midtown in New York, USA

Menu Overview

Emack & Bolio's Ice Cream: Midtown offers an inviting escape for ice cream lovers in the heart of New York City. Located at 1005 2nd Ave, this shop presents a vibrant menu that blends classic favorites with inventive creations. Walking in, the lively ambiance and friendly staff immediately set the tone for a delightful experience.

The menu’s highlights center around flavors like Oreo, Blueberry Crumble, Oreo-Chocolate Ice Cream Cake, Espresso, and the iconic Chocolate Flake. Each flavor embodies a balance of textures and tastes — from the crumbly Oreo bits to the smooth, rich espresso-infused scoops. Their toasted s’more flavor stands out remarkably, offering a luscious mix of creamy ice cream, crunchy cracker pieces, and fluffy marshmallow that melts effortlessly on the tongue. It’s a harmonious blend that feels thoughtfully crafted and perfectly layered.

Beyond ice cream, Emack & Bolio’s impresses with its housemade Belgium Liege waffles, served plain or in a box with decadent hot fudge and caramel. The waffles themselves are golden and crisp, with pearl sugar for added sweetness and texture. This pairing elevates the dessert experience, adding a satisfying contrast between warm, chewy waffles and cold, creamy ice cream.

The beverage choices complement the sweet offerings well. Options like the REMIX iced “OSLO” coffee blend with vanilla bean speck ice cream and the Arnold Palmer REMIX with lemon sorbet add refreshing depth. Their homemade iced teas, either sweetened or unsweetened, provide a crisp palate cleanser after indulging.

Variety is a hallmark here, from the innovative, less-sweet profiles like the no sugar added Butter Pecan, to the playful Doggie Sundae—vanilla low-fat yogurt with a Milkbone for your canine companion. It’s clear Emack & Bolio’s considers every guest, human and furry alike.

Customer experiences reflect this quality and diversity. Some appreciate the light yet flavorful nature of the ice cream, noting it’s neither overpoweringly sweet nor heavy. The Nutella with rice crispy cone has received praise for pairing brilliantly with classic flavors like Oreo, delivering a creative spin on traditional cones. Regular patrons highlight the vast flavor selection and enjoy coming back to try new favorites, with grasshopper pie and toasted s’mores often mentioned as must-tries.

The welcoming atmosphere, coupled with fast and friendly service, rounds out the experience. Seating inside and out offers a casual place to savor a treat or linger with friends. While some find cake options on the pricier side, the pints and cones provide approachable ways to enjoy the brand’s craftsmanship.

In essence, Emack & Bolio’s Midtown stands as a neighborhood gem—one that respects ice cream’s classic roots yet pushes the envelope with textures, flavors, and thoughtful pairings. Whether stopping by for a midday pick-me-up or a sweet evening indulgence, this spot makes ice cream exciting again.